Israeli Dog (Not a stray)
A Jerusalem rabbinical court recently sentenced a wandering dog to death by stoning. The cruel sentence stemmed from the suspicion that the hound was the reincarnation of a famous secular lawyer, who insulted the court's judges 20 years ago.
Several weeks ago, according to the Behadrei Hadarim website, a large dog entered the Monetary Affairs Court near the ultra-Orthodox neighborhood of Mea Shearim. The dog scared the court's visitors and, to their surprise, refused to leave even after they attempted to drive him away.
Still offended, one of the judges sentenced the poor animal to death by stoning, recruiting the neighborhood's children to carry out the order. Luckily, the dog managed to escape.
One of the judges suddenly recalled that about 20 years ago, a famous secular lawyer who insulted the court was cursed by the panel of judges, who wished that his spirit would move on to the body of a dog (considered an impure animal by Halacha). The lawyer passed away several years ago.
Read more at YNet.
The YNet story is dated June 16, 2011, but the story was already revealed to be bogus the day before!
June 15, 2011:
Remember the story of the dog that appeared at the gates of the beis din in mea Shearim? They could not chase it away, and supposedly had decided it was a gilgul of someone who had shamed the dayanim many years earlier. they supposedly had kids stone it and chase it away.
The story raised a ruckus at the time, and the organization against cruelty to animals even filed a complaint against the beis din, all the while the head of the beis din denied the allegations.
Today, the Maariv newspaper ran a "clarification" and apology about that story, saying the rav had said there is no basis for abusing the dog, not halachically and not logically. The rav had also said that city hall had sent their dog catcher to collect the dog from the premises of the beis din. The newspaper apologizes for the misleading headlines from when it was reported.
Read more at LifeinIsrael.com.
Meanwhile, the YNet story, which was proven to be a lie even before YNet decided to publish it, has gone viral and picked up by the BBC and other news outlets. The YNet story has almost 200 talkbacks, most of them crazy with outrage and hate against the Orthodox population.
The story, which is a total fiction, originated in the Hebrew secular media, with each iteration becoming more and more grotesque for comic effect and because hey, everybody hates the Haredim. And because this slander was published IN HEBREW, the general media then picked it up without question.
The Jerusalem Rabbinical Court issued a statement:
June 2, 2011, Sivan 5771
At the beginning of this month, it was reported in various media outlets that a dog wandered into the Beth Din during proceedings, and allegedly was sentenced to be killed by stones at the hand of the judges.
One can see how the story changes and grows out of all proportion from one media story to the next, in this order:
1. At first it was reported that the Beth Din decided that the dog was a reincarnation of some person.
2. The next version reported that the Beth Din ordered children to pelt the dog with stones.
3. The next version reported that the dog was actually stoned to death!
This story never happened and never existed. The dissemination of this take has brought great harm upon the rabbis and judges of the Beth Din who donate their time and knowledge for over twelve years, without receiving payment of any kind. The media outlets which published this story without bothering to verify it with the Beth Din, or who received a statement from the Beth Din and then ignored it, have all committed libel and slander.
Because there is a large population that is totally ignorant of Jewish laws and customs, who may be led in error to believe this tale, the Beth Din issues this detailed explanation:
This was an attempt at "black humor" on the part of the author, a pointless joke that is not even funny. The author perhaps wished to confuse or embarrass his audience for their ignorance, because he had no doubt that his words would be taken seriously.
There is absolutely no basis for such a thing, not in halachah and not in common sense. There never was a case of stoning of a dog or any other animal in the Jewish religion, not during the time of the Temple nor during the time of the Patriarch Abraham. There is no mention of any such thing in the Torah, nor in the Prophets or the holy Writings, it is simply a figment of the imagination that never happened and never existed.
The only part of this story which is accurate, is that a dog--a bitch and not a male dog as reported by the media--a bitch pregnant with puppies--who wandered into the Beth Din and sat down in a corner of the room. And the neighborhood children who had probably never seen a dog before, shouted with delight and glee at the sight, outside of the Beth Din there gathered perhaps hundreds of children who came to catch a glimpse of the dog. They are used to seeing stray cats, but dogs are rare, and they all wanted to see the sight.
The only action that was taken after the dog entered the courtroom and quietly found a place to rest, was to call the city officials in charge of animal control to come and remove the dog, and this can be verified with the authorities.
Any embellishment to this simple fact, comes from the imagination and bitter sense of humor of the author who fabricated it, namely: there was no reincarnation, no mention of any lawyer who passed away 20 years ago, no correction or punishment recommended, and no stoning took place.
Fabrications of this type come very close to the classic blood libel, and one wonders why the author, with his peculiar brand of sick humor, did not also include in his tale how the dog was slaughtered and its blood collected in a jar for the purpose of mixing into next year's shmurah matzah (something which the entire world knows is a falsehood and has never happened).
In addition:
The court remained in session for the entire afternoon, listening to the cases of dozens of litigants who had been scheduled for that day. You can interview each and every one of them as witnesses who saw what happened to the dog. Everyone will testify that nothing at all happened!
Therefore, the entire media report of stoning, or of giving the order to stone, is not based on any eyewitnesses or observed fact!
This speaks for itself.
The Secretariat of the Beth Din. [excerpt translated by Babushka]
Read more at Harry's Place.
Babushka has sent an email to YNet requesting a retraction and clarification, at the present time the number of hateful talkbacks is approaching 200 and YNet has not withdrawn this bogus story.
Update: YNet has finally removed the article from their website, 1:30PM June 21, 2011.
Recent Comments